Showing posts with label Andrew Lloyd Webber. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Andrew Lloyd Webber. Show all posts

Tuesday, 27 January 2009

Jesus Christ Superstar


Ever since my father died just over a year ago, my stepmother has been involved in the long process of clearing out his stuff (I didn’t realise what a hoarder he was) and passing on family possessions to me and my sister. Recently, I was asked to look through his meagre collection of old LPs and take what I wanted. After a nostalgic 20 minutes or so I came away with about half a dozen 1950s discs in their battered sleeves that I remembered from my childhood. They comprised mainly jazz and swing from that era together with my mother’s proudest possession, ‘The Best of Pat Boone’.

But amongst these relics of a by-gone age was a slightly younger relic, a copy of the original ‘concept’ recording of ‘Jesus Christ Superstar’ from 1970. I remember buying this for Dad when it came out and being rather shocked that he wanted it in the first place as it was a million miles away from Sid Philips, Winifred Atwell and the Clark Sisters.

I have now transferred it to MP3 and had a bash at removing the worst of the scratches and pops (of which there were many) and have listened to it anew after 30 odd years. We all know Andrew Lloyd-Webber from his West End shows but this recording reveals him as a young 20-year-old composer caught between wanting to be either Led Zeppelin, Rogers and Hammerstein or the Berlin Philharmonic and contriving to be all three at the same time. It is an intriguing mixture. JCS has all the hallmarks of his later musical theatre leanings with typical ‘show’ songs and orchestral flourishes yet it is infused with a streak of real rock ‘n’ roll (or rock ‘n’ funk to be strictly accurate) which is now missing presumed dead in current work.

The muscular backbone of this album has been achieved by installing Joe Cocker’s backing band, the Grease Band, as house musicians, a bunch of hairy rockers including guitarists Henry McCullough and Neil Hubbard, bassist Alan Spenner and drummer Bruce Rowland, who seem to revel in the complexities of the shifting time signatures (lots of 7/4 – eek!) and modulating keys. It also benefits enormously from the vocal talents of Murray Head, Yvonne Elliman and Barry Dennen and the inspired casting of Deep Purple’s Ian Gillian as Jesus, who lends real weight to the part yet still manages to bring the looseness of popular singing to a table usually inhabited by stiffer ‘classical’ singers. In short, this album rocks. You’d be hard pushed to guess that it came from the pen of Lloyd-Webber if you didn’t already know. The later film and stage show soundtracks have mellowed JCS and stripped out the rawness but the original concept album still retains it in spades.

Predictably, it doesn’t quite escape from its time and place. The young Tim Rice’s thought-provoking lyrics have a vaguely late 60s hippyish tinge to them, (as does some of the music - think Hair) but are clever and astute as well, telling the story, which ends with the crucifixion, in very human terms and giving each character a legitimate voice and motivation. He steers clear of any ‘faith’ issues – there are no ‘miracles’, nor resurrection – thus allowing agnostics like me and those of non-Christian faiths access what is a compelling, yet darkly moving tragedy. Although dated, the whole thing has an irresistible aura to it and it never fails to leave me buzzing with emotional turmoil.

I’m very glad that this LP has come back into my possession. It could well be a modern classic and irrespective of what you think of Lloyd-Webber today, I would recommend that everybody listens to it at least once.

Sunday, 20 April 2008

I'd Do Anything...sort of


So here we go again with another BBC/Andrew Lloyd-Webber reality audition TV show, ‘I’d Do Anything’ where another West End star will be chosen by the public. You know what the worst thing is about TV singing talent shows? It’s the way the results can be manipulated. In the case of the ‘competition’ type shows like IDA, the control of manipulation lies with the organisers, judging panel and ‘trainers’. So if you want to create your own show, this is how you do it.

1. First plan out your talent show and then decide who is going to win.

2. The potential winner is then given an extremely well known and popular song to sing. This is absolutely key because an audience will always respond to a favourite song almost irrespective of the talent or personality of the singer. The song should be chosen so that it fits the audience demographic, so a sixties song is matched to a middle-aged audience and so on. There are always memories attached to songs, most of which are happy, so a well-matched song is bound to strike a few chords. (Note - the ‘Stars in their Eyes’ entrant who won with Chris de Burgh’s ‘Lady in Red’ got it absolutely right. His was not a killer impersonation but the song chosen was a tremendously popular, sentimental song that virtually everybody in that audience had last-danced to in their youth. How could he fail?)

3. Conversely, the most talented singer in the competition is given a slightly bizarre yet extremely difficult song to attempt. When it doesn’t quite come off, the judging panel sympathizes with the following:
‘We gave you a tough song this week because we felt your talent could do it justice, but unfortunately it didn’t quite convince. Nevertheless it was still a great performance.’
Of course the last sentence attempts to show balance but the damage has been done and the seed of doom has been sown with the audience.

4. The remainder of the competitors are given slightly less popular or wrong demographic songs than the proposed winner (so Bing Crosby in front of a twenty-something audience and Puff Daddy for old age pensioners). This ensures that they will not shine in quite the same way. Of course, if it doesn’t work one week there is always the following week and eventually the ‘right’ person will emerge.

In these sorts of shows it is really the music that is under scrutiny, not the performers and the music is the one thing that the organisers have under their complete control. Hence results can be influenced, as generally the performer has little control of the song choice and must perform as best they can on an uneven playing field.

Simple really. Good luck with your show.